Opinion

Could the US use a little protectionism?

The Christian Science Monitor - Tue Dec 15, 5:05 PM ET

Would a touch of protectionism do the United States some good? Protectionism is generally taboo among policymakers and economists. “Being called a protectionist is only slightly better than being called a criminal,” states Dean Baker, codirector of the Center for Economic and Policy Research, a liberal Washington think tank. It is safe today, though, to take a tough line on trade disputes and, indirectly, do more to protect American interests because the financial crisis has blunted the international program for lowering trade barriers. “Last year’s experience has made people much more wary,” says Robert Weissman, president of Public Citizen. The nonprofit consumer advocacy group worries that World Trade Organization (WTO) deals will effectively block reregulation of the nation’s financial industry. “People don’t believe the promises of free trade have been met,” says Andy Gussert, national director of Citizens Trade Campaign, a major coalition of environmental, labor, consumer, family farm, religious, and other civil society groups. It aims to block Bush-era trade deals negotiated with Colombia, South Korea, and Panama, and to seek renegotiation of such important trade deals as NAFTA (involving Canada, the US, and Mexico) and CAFTA (Central America and the US). As a result, prospects for the eight-year-old Doha Round of global trade negotiations under the 153-nation WTO are extremely dim. And with a US president preoccupied with healthcare reform, financial regulation, and the economy, trade liberalization will not get a boost from the country that is normally the biggest fan of breaking down trade barriers. Key countries like India and China “are ready to do business, but the US is not,” says Harald Malmgren, a Washington consulting economist who helped negotiate the Kennedy Round of trade talks decades ago. The huge US trade deficit suggests that it has a relatively open market to imports and is not especially protective. The deficit also indicates that at a time of high unemployment, the US is losing jobs to China and other countries with trade surpluses. To start tackling this problem, the Obama administration in September imposed a bit of legal protectionism. It slapped high tariffs on Chinese tire imports for three years, starting at 35 percent. One of the terms for admitting China into the WTO was a provision allowing an importing nation to take such tariff action when surging imports “threaten to or cause market disruption.” Mr. Malmgren suspects Washington law firms will stir up business by finding other industries facing keen Chinese competition. “We could get a series of cases,” he says. Some trade experts see China as predatory in its trade policies. It manipulates its currency to give its exporters a price advantage, thereby creating jobs for millions of ex-farmers. It requires foreign corporate investors to bring their advanced technology with them and insists that its own companies weigh national interests in their plans. The US is “being outgamed economically – losing industries and racking up large trade deficits,” noted a 2006 paper by three prominent economists for Levy Economics Institute of Bard College. They suggest various countermeasures but insist they aren’t protectionism. Mr. Baker has an unusual solution: The US should start buying Chinese yuan on the foreign exchange markets at 5 yuan to a dollar, rather than the current price of about 7 to 1. That would push up the price of Chinese goods. Protectionism? Or just fair trade?

  • You're a Student of History, And I'm Not HuffingtonPost.com - Mon Dec 14, 2:15 PM ET

    Read Harry Shearer's other articles on HuffingtonPost.com

  • In a Big-Issue Week, Joblessness Remains the Biggest Issue The Nation - Wed Dec 2, 10:05 AM ET

    The Nation -- The official unemployment rate of 10.2 percent is the worst in a quarter century.

  • The Year of the Political Jackass RealClearPolitics.com - Wed Dec 16, 1:00 AM ET

    It was a year for the political jackass. Headlines were filled with politicians' private improprieties exposed.

  • Interview with Marsha Blackburn RealClearPolitics.com - Tue Dec 15, 1:00 AM ET

    Republican Rep. Marsha Blackburn, who represents the 7th Congressional District of Tennessee, spoke with RealClearPolitics in a phone interview Monday afternoon to discuss politics, health care and the climate change summit in Copenhagen, which she will be attending this week.

  • Obama and 'fat cat' bankers. It’s about more than lending. The Christian Science Monitor - Tue Dec 15, 12:01 PM ET

    At some point in 2009, a power shift occurred in US politics. Big financial institutions went from needing Washington’s help in avoiding an abyss to Washington seeking their help for economic recovery and job creation. 

  • What Will Democrats Do? Susan Estrich - Wed Dec 16, 3:00 AM ET

    Creators Syndicate - Whatever it takes.

  • Obama Brings the Gitmolympics Home Michelle Malkin - Wed Dec 16, 3:00 AM ET

    Creators Syndicate - President Obama's hometown cronies lost their bid to bring the 2016 Olympic Games to the Windy City. But this week they got a consolation prize: the Gitmolympics. On Tuesday, the White House went public with its official plans to purchase the Thomson Correctional Facility from financially strapped Illinois to house Guantanamo Bay detainees. The War on Terror meets the Chicago Way.

  • Preferring Liberals in Both Parties Brent Bozell III - Wed Dec 16, 3:00 AM ET

    Creators Syndicate - Liberal newspaper people are so predictable when it comes to internal party fights. If it's inside the Republican Party, it's the conservative Republicans who are wrong. If inside the Democratic Party, it's the conservative Democrats who are wrong.

  • Civil Rights Commission Blunders Again Mona Charen - Tue Dec 15, 3:00 AM ET

    Creators Syndicate - The U.S. Civil Rights Commission (yes, it's still around and yes, it's outlived its usefulness) is about to subtract from national wisdom about college admissions by focusing on exactly the wrong problem.

  • Fat City Pat Buchanan - Tue Dec 15, 3:00 AM ET

    Creators Syndicate - "It's time to stop worrying about the deficit — and start panicking about the debt," the Washington Post editorial began. "The fiscal situation was serious before the recession. It is now dire."

  • WE, THE PEOPLE, ARE NOT AT WAR Richard Reeves - Mon Dec 14, 7:58 PM ET

    WASHINGTON -- So, our extraordinarily rational and articulate president went to Norway to receive the Nobel Peace Prize and identified himself as a wartime commander-in-chief. True, but he neglected to mention that his nation is not at war.

  • Women and the GOP The Weekly Standard - Mon Dec 14, 1:36 PM ET

    Washington (The Weekly Standard) Vol. 015, Issue 14 - 12/21/2009 - In early November, Democratic representative Debbie Wasserman Schultz of Florida accused House Republicans of giving women "back-of-the-hand treatment" during a parliamentary dust-up over a health care debate.

  • Kim Jong Il Gets a Free Pass The Weekly Standard - Mon Dec 14, 1:36 PM ET

    Washington (The Weekly Standard) Vol. 015, Issue 14 - 12/21/2009 - In his Nobel acceptance speech last week, President Obama spoke eloquently on what he called a "just peace"--a peace that is not possible without the recognition of basic human rights. Where human rights are not protected, "peace is a hollow promise," he said.

  • Bye Bye Blanche The Weekly Standard - Mon Dec 14, 1:36 PM ET

    Washington (The Weekly Standard) Vol. 015, Issue 14 - 12/21/2009 - Even before she became the swing vote that forced consideration of Obamacare onto the Senate floor, two-term Arkansas senator Blanche Lambert Lincoln had a dubious distinction: "For 2010, she may be the most endangered Democratic senator in the country," says Public Policy Polling head Dean Debnam.

  • A Little Learning . . . The Weekly Standard - Mon Dec 14, 1:36 PM ET

    Washington (The Weekly Standard) Vol. 015, Issue 14 - 12/21/2009 - The campaign for the 1988 Democratic presidential nomination offered a glimpse into the soul of Joe Biden. Asked by a prospective voter where he went to law school, Biden responded with a tirade that, had the claims been true, would have been bizarre. But as most of them were outright lies, it qualifies as one of the strangest political statements on record:

  • Islam U. The Weekly Standard - Mon Dec 14, 1:35 PM ET

    Washington (The Daily Standard) - Zaytuna College, which plans to be the first accredited Muslim college in the United States, is set to open next fall in Berkeley, California.

  • Standing Up for Liberty The Weekly Standard - Mon Dec 14, 1:35 PM ET

    Washington (The Weekly Standard) Vol. 015, Issue 14 - 12/21/2009 - The triumph of Reaganism, as represented by the passage of the Kemp-Roth tax cuts in 1981, was a declaration of intellectual independence by conservatives and Republicans who decided to no longer be "tax collectors for the welfare state."Equally, the current battle to defeat plans for a national health insurance program will be a richer victory if conservatives and Republicans not only defeat the proposed legislation, but articulate a vision that rejects the fearful, risk-averse attitude intrinsic to the bills passed by the House and proposed in the Senate.

  • The Real Lessons of 1994 The Weekly Standard - Mon Dec 14, 1:35 PM ET

    Washington (The Weekly Standard) Vol. 015, Issue 14 - 12/21/2009 - Democratic senators and congressmen have been trying to convince each other, particularly their more conservative colleagues, that they'll all be better off in the 2010 elections--and will avoid a repeat of their 1994 debacle--if they pass Obama-care.

  • From Awful to Worse The Weekly Standard - Mon Dec 14, 1:35 PM ET

    Washington (The Weekly Standard) Vol. 015, Issue 14 - 12/21/2009 - The Obama administration and congressional Democrats long ago gave up any pretense of working to rationally reform American health care.

  • Belgium Waffles The Weekly Standard - Mon Dec 14, 1:35 PM ET

    Washington (The Weekly Standard) Vol. 015, Issue 14 - 12/21/2009 - Ever since it was carved by treaty out of the Dutch, French, and German borderlands after the Napoleonic wars, Belgium has been an odd kind of country--short on space, sunlight, and national identity.

Most Popular Opinion

  • Ron Paul's Hour of Power Pat Buchanan - Fri Dec 11, 3:00 AM ET

    Creators Syndicate - The decades-long campaign of Ron Paul to have the Government Accountability Office do a full audit of the Federal Reserve now has 313 sponsors in the House.

  • Hollywood and Howard Zinn's Marxist Education Project Michelle Malkin - Fri Dec 11, 3:00 AM ET

    Creators Syndicate - The two most important questions for society, according to the Greek philosopher Plato, are these: What will we teach our children? And who will teach them? Left-wing celebrities have teamed up with one of America's most radical historians to take control of the classroom in the name of "social justice." Parents, beware: This Hollywood-backed Marxist education project may be coming to a school near you.

  • A Tiger Woods lesson for the public: Infidelity hurts The Christian Science Monitor - Mon Dec 14, 4:17 PM ET

    The cascade of news about Tiger Woods since his Escalade escapade has largely been driven by the public’s interest in celebrity, mystery, and often pure salaciousness. Only lately has the negative fallout from his secret infidelity begun to hit home: lost corporate sponsors, a stunning golf career on hold, and most of all, a marriage and family in jeopardy.